In honor of the American Revolution’s 250th anniversary, I am writing about a patriot whose Nebraska descendants include Wymore, McMains, Hadden, McKamey, Lockhard, Renschler, and many others.
Frederick Wymore is listed in 1,346 public trees at Ancestry.com. None of them has completely correct information; most assign him the wrong father, illustrating why you should not copy data from other family trees.
Frederick was likely born in Pennsylvania to Germanic ancestors—then often called “Dutch”— from the Palatinate region of what later became Germany. Proof of his birthplace and birth year has not been found. The earliest record giving him an age is the 1770 Botetourt County, Virginia, delinquent tax list, where he appears as a tithe (age 21 or older), indicating a birth year of 1749 or earlier.
In 1749, the Greenbrier Land Company, established by politically connected men, was granted 100,000 acres in the wilderness, not in a single tract, but for any land the company claimed. When the first settlers arrived, they claimed their land by “tomahawk rights”: if they could defend it, it was theirs. However, the Indians fought fiercely to protect their lands, driving out the settlers. The French and Indian War (1754 to 1763) was won by the British. In 1769, surveying and settlement resumed in what was then a part of Augusta County, Virginia. But the settlers had problems attaining clear title to their land. In 1777, a petition by the inhabitants of Greenbrier in the county of Botetourt to the Assembly of the Commonwealth of Virginia was signed by 75 landowners. The petition complained that they had not been given valid title to their lands by “mercenary strangers.” They had “long served as a barrier on the frontiers of the colony against the savages by whose cruelty many have lossed (sic) their lives.” The courthouse was a long way off, separated by a large chain of mountains. The petition asked that a new county be “struck off” and outlined the eastern boundary as the “turns of the west from the east waters.” The Commonwealth agreed, and Greenbrier County was formed as of March 1, 1778. However, the residents’ land problems did not end, and on June 13, 1783, another petition, signed by 280 men, was submitted to the Virginia legislature. Among the signers were Frederick Wimer and his father-in-law, James Morrow Sr. I do not know if the legislature took action, but the first Greenbrier County Land Book is dated 1783.
Mathew’s Trading Post, the first trading post in present-day Greenbrier County, stood on the Greenbrier River near the mouth of Howards Creek. The Greenbrier Historical Society holds two account books covering the period from April 1771 through January 1773.
Fred “Wighmore” made purchases there, including loaf sugar, between May 1771 and January 1773. John “Wighmore” and his wife also made purchases during that period, including a pair of “treaces,” 18 yards of linen, and one dozen knives and forks. Barbara Wymore (Frederick’s sister) purchased sundries on Dec 9, 1771.
John Wymore, likely Frederick’s father, had 280 acres on Spring Lick Creek surveyed in 1774. Due to the ownership problems at the time, it was never exchanged for a patent or grant.
Frederick married Jane Morrow, daughter of James Morrow, Sr., about 1775 in Botetourt County, where both lived. No record of the marriage has been found; however, her father’s will, dated November 6, 1791, in Greenbrier County, names his daughter Jane Wymer.
No complete roster has been found for Greenbrier men who served in the Revolutionary War. Greenbrier had an organized militia regiment, the 79th Regiment, made up of free white males age 16 and older; 732 of whom lived in the county. Many known veterans did not go east to join the Continental Army. Instead, they went west to defend the settlements against Indian attacks encouraged by the British. In 1781, Virginia’s governor ordered a draft of 137 men from Greenbrier County to serve under George Rogers Clark.
Greenbrier County Court Orders begin on November 25, 1780. On August 20, 1783, the court ordered the deposition of “Fred’ch Wimer” in a case involving Archibald and Cessely Smithers. Unfortunately, the deposition no longer exists.
Greenbrier County Survey Entry Records began in January 1780. On May 21, the entry of Frederick Wimore, “assignee of Robert Clendennan, 200 State Warrant for 1434.5 acres adjoining the lands of John Collison and George Cutlip, at a place known by the name of David Cutlip’s Improvement,” was ordered lifted and removed. Apparently, the land titles mess caused Frederick to lose ownership of this land.
The 1790 and 1800 censuses for Virginia and Kentucky are lost. Fortunately, Greenbrier tax lists beginning in 1782 survive. Frederick is listed in 1783 with 3 horses and 4 cattle.
The settlers’ problems with obtaining clear title to their lands probably influenced the Wymore family to search for land in what was then Kentucky County, Virginia. Established in 1776, it existed for only four years until 1780, when it was replaced by three counties, including Fayette, with Lexington as the county seat.
The 350-mile trip from Greenbrier County, down the Wilderness Road, through the Cumberland Gap, and up to the site of Lexington was grueling and fraught with danger. It was not a road, but a path through the mountains wide enough for a man on horseback. If a small group was caught by Indians, they were all killed, or the women and children were carried into brutal captivity. About 1784, Charles Wymore (brother to Frederick) and the Smethers family, including four children, were all killed by Indians while coming through the wilderness to Lexington.
Frederick’s father, John Wymore, his wife Lucy, and the younger children traveled the Wilderness Road to Kentucky in the fall of 1779. At that time, only a log blockhouse and four cabins, surrounded by a palisade, had been built. Lucy Wymore was the second white woman at Lexington. Mrs. Morrison, the first woman at Lexington, in an interview years later, said, “Her heart sank when the first person she saw (among the newcomers) was a rough old Dutch woman.” (Germans were called “Dutch” at that time.)
The “Citizens Compact,” which established Lexington, Virginia (now Kentucky), was signed on January 25, 1780, by 47 settlers, including Frederick Wimor, James Morrow, John Wimer, Jacob Wimer, and John Wimer Jr. James Morrow was Frederick’s father-in-law; John was Frederick’s father; John Jr. was Frederick’s brother; and Jacob, I haven’t identified.
The log cabin with the “X” on the roof was the one occupied by the John Wymore family.
In March 1781, John Wymore Sr. was killed by Indians outside the Lexington fort. He and Henry McDaniel were out cutting timber to repair the fort. McDaniel went to the top of a hill to scout for Indians. “When McDaniel got to the top of the hill, he saw Indians coming and gave the alarm for Wymore to run. Wymore dropped his axe and run (sic), but McDaniel, being young and active, overtook the old man and passed him. When the Indian shot Wymore, three Indians ran up to scalp him. McDaniel jumped behind a large cherry tree, raised his gun, and shot one of them. Took him right over the eyebrow, and laid him down by the side of Wymore. The other Indians put off as soon as they got the scalp, leaving the dead Indian behind. I saw him there the next morning.” The Indian was scalped, and “his scalp hung on a string on a pole so the wind would blow it about to mortify the Indians. The men hung the head of the dead Indian in that wild cherry tree and cut up his frame for the hogs. No other man was killed at Lexington but my father,” recalled his son Martin.
Frederick must have traveled back and forth between Lexington and Greenbrier County, as he is listed on a 1782 tax list, a 1783 court order, and a 1783 landholders’ petition, all in Greenbrier.
In October 1781, the citizens of the south side of the Greenbrier River petitioned the General Assembly of Virginia, stating that they were situated on the frontier and “have suffered much by the depredations of the Indians for many years, neither are there any prospects of those enemies being brought to a stand as long as the bloody hand of George of England is able to reach us.” Notwithstanding, their complaint was that they were expected to furnish a great amount of money or crop for building a wagon road from Fort Union, on the north side of the Greenbrier River, through Botetourt County and part of Augusta to the warm springs, a distance of 48 miles, passing through mountains and a country overrun with Indians. The signers included Frederick Wymore, Charles Wymore, James Morrow Sr., and James Morrow Jr. Signing this petition is considered by the DAR and SAR to be patriotic service for the Revolution.
Frederick apparently moved permanently to Kentucky in 1787, as he appears annually on the Fayette County tax lists until 1799, when he is listed in the newly formed Jessamine County. In August 1796, Frederick advertised in the Kentucky Gazette “73 acres of land for sale on the waters of Hickman Creek, eight miles from Lexington.” Thirty of the acres were cleared and included a bearing peach orchard and two cabins. However, the land wasn’t sold until 1816, when it was sold for “100 pounds current Kentucky money.”
The Wymores must have raised tobacco, as Frederick and John both signed a 1787 petition from inhabitants of Fayette County to the Virginia House of Delegates requesting that a tobacco inspection station be established on the north side of the Kentucky River at the mouth of Hickman Creek. The request was granted.
Both Frederick and his brother John owned slaves. The first mention I find is the 1787 Fayette County, Kentucky tax list. John was taxed for one slave over 16 years and two under 16. It wasn’t until 1800 in Jessamine County that Frederick was taxed for one black over 16 years old. The 1820 census of Owen County lists Frederick with one female slave over 45 years old. The last year he was taxed for a slave was 1823. I have not found a record of any Wymore buying or selling a slave, nor does any family member have a slave after 1823. Perhaps the female slave over 45 years old in 1820 died in 1823.
Unfortunately, the Fayette County courthouse in Lexington burned in 1803, destroying records from short-lived Kentucky County, Virginia, and early Fayette County. The loss of early marriage, probate, deed, and court records makes research more difficult, and some questions may never be answered. Fortunately, the state held the tax lists, which survive.
In the mid-1820s, following the Federal Land Act of 1820, the Frederick Wymore extended family broke with Kentucky and moved across the Ohio River into Indiana. What motivated them to start over again on the prairies of Parke and Montgomery Counties? Obviously, one motive was financial. In April 1827, Frederick and Jane sold 100 acres on Stevens Creek in Owen County, Kentucky for $850. In September 1827, he received his patent for 80 acres in Parke County, Indiana. The federal land cost $1.25 an acre or $100.
Frederick wrote a will dated July 29, 1829, in Parke County, naming his children, James, John, Samuel, George, William, Thomas, Nancy, and Susan. Frederick’s will was not probated until January 10, 1846, in Montgomery County, when his heirs were selling land that had been his. He is not listed on the June 1830 census, indicating that he died between July 29, 1829, and June 1830. His wife Jane had died earlier, likely in Owen County, Kentucky, between the August 1820 census and July 1822 when Frederick sold land to the Long Ridge Baptist Church, and no wife signed the deed with him. The locations of their graves are lost to time.
In later years, Frederick and Jane’s descendants swept across the United States with the movement of the frontier, pioneering in Missouri, Iowa, Nebraska, Kansas, California, Oregon, and Washington.
























